Saturday, Oct 27, 2012 at 13:26
A Spot is, what I would consider to be on the same page as en EPIRB. It's small, portable and can be used with minimal input (in comparison to say a HF or satphone) if you happen to be semi conscious or suffering serious injuries.
The benefit these devices have as emergency devices is that they are portable. Now when it comes to hard wiring them, the better the hard wiring job, the more difficult it is to get out of the vehicle.
Now if we look more closely at the device, to hard wire one, we have 2 options.
Firstly we can solder on to the battery connections or make up "dummy batteries" and have the power running in through them still utilising the battery connections. Soldering directly onto the existing connections will then have implications with batteries when you do put them in and you won't be able to fit the cover on properly and the batteries can become dislodged or fall out.
The other option is to run the cables into the unit itself. Sounds like a great idea however your water/dust proofing factor goes out the window.
So either option we take, we have reduced the capability of the device. Now let's look at some scenarios.
1. Roll your car
2. Car catches on fire
3. You want to take the device for a bush walk
-First step in every case is to disconnect it from the power supply. Sounds easy until you apply the stress factors in scenario 1 and 2.
-Second step, let's put the batteries in. Again, high pressure, high stress (without taking into account potential injuries) and your cognitive functions diminish. So getting batteries in becomes a mission but that's only if you remembered where you placed them and also to get them out of the car.
-Third step, alright, we remembered the batteries, held ourselves together for long enough to get them in, now lets activate it. Whoops, the
water must have got in when I was walking though the
creek in scenario 3 and now it doesn't work.......
The biggest down fall with these devices is the batteries. Obviously they are a little different in nature to an EPIRB but the battery life in an epirb is a mind resting factor. By messaing around with the devices weakest point you are playing with fire and it would seriously deplete the confidence I have in them and that is why I would be disregarding the emergency functions if I was to play around with the power supply.
FollowupID:
773324