Friday, Nov 09, 2012 at 14:41
Yes I have researched it.
The first thing to look at is the specifications the oil meets or exceeds, and then who actually guarantees the oil meets those specifications.
Knowing a little about oil chemistry and what is done to achieve certain things and knowing a little about the oil specs, helps
Secondly you can make some simple observations, such as the amount of sludge on the interiour of the engine.
Sticking ya finger in the oil filler and seeing what comes out is a start, or looking at the underside of the rocker cover and observing the amount of sludge or varnish there.
Looking at the oil when you drain it and having a scrape of the bottom of the sump while you have the plug out.
making observations of engines at the time of reconditioning
And of course the sceptics will poo poo the fact that changing to a good quality correctly selected oil can improve the performance of engines over time...actually over a quite short time.
Trusting independent testing of oils.
Persoanlly I use a diesel spec oil, in all my engines.
Main stream retail oils probably do not get the scrutiny that diesel spec oils get. there are not single users that consume the huge volumes or have the testing facilities for main stream oils like there are with diesel spec oils.
I am not talking main stream retail oils, I view them mostly as wasted money.
There are many people who will testify to improvements when changing to the 3 specified and proven diesel spec oils from over priced retail oils.
The transport industry uses these oils in massive volumes and those that use them have very large sums of money invested in their engines.......these people do analise and test...if the oils do not do the job they simply don't sell.
Those top 3 oils are
mobil devlac,
caltex dello and shell rimular...there is very little to seperate them and they all meet the same group of specifications and they are all mixed fleet oils that will run happily in diesel and petrol engines. They are all made and guaranteed to the same specification worldwide.
It is very common for people to post on forums when they are having problems with their older toyotas, blowing smoke and using oil after changing to some funky retail oil.
When they change back to one of the popular 15w40 diesel spec oils the problem goes away.
Most of the issues with oil will not be the friction and wear issues the advertising goes on with. it will be sludging due to the oil breaking down with heat and it failing to clean and suspend solids.
A chealpy made oil...not necessarily cheap to buy will be made of inferiour base oils and will rely on viscosity modifiers to achieve its spec.
these cheaply made oils will not maintain specification or performence anywhere near as long as a quality oil.
They will break down and produce sludge and varnish, not maintain viscosity and will not adequately suspend meterial so it can be dealt with by the filter.
result sludge and franish on the inside of the motor, sediment in the bottom of the sump, a PCV tract that is not clean and may be blocked..and so
forth.
I used to be a fancy retail oil man...since changing to diesel spec oils I have personally observed my engines are significantly cleaner inside and there are lots of niggly little problems that simply don't occur any more.
there are many who have doe the same and will testify the same.
AND we are all paying a hell of a lot less for our oil.
olcoolone......mate I think we are probalby singing from the same song book......just a different rendition.
Those who sell retail oil have been having a lend of us for a very long time.
cheers
FollowupID:
774178