Friday, Dec 21, 2012 at 13:00
I sick reading this “Amateur Transmitter” bashing posts – people who doing so hmmm…. How to say politely… Not that competent. All this rubbish about interference (sometimes even harmful!) make no more sense that End Of Universe that suppose to came today. No one from type approval advocates ever thought that ancient Codan 6924 (great rig, BTW) is type approval while supermodern Yaesu FTDX30000 is not. Does anyone seriously reckon that FTDX30000 will produce more interference that 6924? If one does then (s)he is complete and absolute idiot.
Also there are lame arguments about superior robustness of commercial equipment vs amateur one. May be (just may be) my Barrett 950 survive nuclear attack while FTDX30000 not. But again valve transmitter circa 1960 has far better chances to survive such attack then any modern digital gizmos. As for using in 4WD – what happens to properly designed and properly made rig? How many of those “rigidness” advocates has top level
UHF radio installed? Bet that majority using cheap chanoze made Unidens and they serving for decades without any problem.
Selcall? Yes, has certain valid merit. But what if one does not really need it? For example to have secondary radio to communicate between cars or between base and bushwalkers? Portable HF is another can of worms – military manpacks from Codan and Barrett not that portable neither particularly cheap and massive overkill for general requirement.
It is boils down to one single point – ACMA does not like us to use amateur equipment. Period. And people who believe that this is because of “safety” can very
well believe that 120km/hr on Hume freeway is incredibly dangerous (legal speed 110) while 100km/hr on twisted gravel alpine road is perfectly safe (legal speed 100).
Well so often legality and safety can be
miles apart.
One can compile thousands of theories why ACMA dislike amateurs equipment, but as far as I can see it boils down to two points – conspiracy theory that they like us to buy commercial equipment (just imagine what happens with prices on new and especially used Codan and Barrett if ACMA allow to use Yaesus, Icoms and Kenwoods!) and valid argument that amateur radios require more knowledge/understanding and almost always more complicate to use. Argument that they easy to tune to any frequency is another lime one – first of all there are plenty of unlocked Barretts and Codans that allow the same and secondly if I have a rifle, then according to this logic nothing can stop me going out and shoot down street just for fun. And second argument cannot stand simple question – why ACMA dislike licensed amateurs to use amateur equipment on VKS737 (and alike) networks. Thus as for me conspiracy theory is prevail.
So please do not show your restricted knowledge and stop bashing amateur equipment – it is damn good nowadays, some models far superior to any commercial ones. It is just against legislation – as simple as this.
FollowupID:
776852