Tuesday, Nov 14, 2006 at 08:24
Finincially and physically difficult, if not impossible to achieve. From a previous posting on this subject:
==================================================
Next to impossible to achieve. As a rule of thumb, 1m diametre pipe for this purpose costs $1000/m ......best case scenario, 2750km, dead straight. So there goes 2.7 Billion dollars. That is without taking in account pump stations ($2m+ per pump station per 100km, best case), balance tanks, surge protection for
water hammer, telemetry, huge valves, redundancy protection, electricity supply to each pump station, etc etc.
The other issue with these types of schemes is that in the process they go through numerous shire who would want to tap into the scheme. It ends up being a nightmare :-) Don't even think about the native title issues :-)
A 1m pipe, ignoring offtakes, would be able to supply 135 Ml per day, which is enough to supply a city the size of
Townsville (150,000) let alone
Brisbane's 2 million + !!!
The numbers we are talking about would put the Snowy Hydro to shame ;-)
=================================================
Rather than take
water from another area, it would make more sense to take ownership of the problem and fix it at a local level. It annoys me when organisations/political parties etc bring up the idea of harvesting
water from "up north" to supply the southerners with something they have misused over time. When the "northerners" ask for a couple of dollars to upgrade roads to basic levels, the old excuse of "the M1 upgrade is more important", or " the river tunnel (
brisbane) is being considered" just doesn't cut it. It seems to me that the larger cities want the best of both worlds,
water and world class roads, higher speed broadband, high speed mobile phone networks etc whereas they really should be looking at compromising on some things and decide what really is important. I realise that it is not that simple, however people need to appreciate what they have and manage what they need smarter.
Just my thoughts....
Andrew
FollowupID:
464693