which caravan?

Hi
My parents are thinking of buying a caravan, would be towed with a new commodore max tow weight 2150kg.
Would like to be able to tow on dirt roads from time to time but mainly on the black top.
Ideal max spend would be $25k so i guess talking second hand.
Size of van around 18 foot approx.
Located in Adelaide.
Any suggestions as to the type/model/brand of van they should be looking for.
I think they need to spend more!
Thanks Lyndon
Now is the only time you own
Decide now what you will,
Place faith not in tomorrow
For the clock may then be still

Member
My Profile  My Position  Send Message

Back Expand Un-Read 0 Moderator

Reply By: Mick - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 09:32

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 09:32
Evernew have built an excellent reputation manufacturing vans for over 40 years. You should be able to find an older one for that price.
AnswerID: 263546

Reply By: Ian from Thermoguard Instruments - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 09:57

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 09:57
You'll get nearly as many recommendations as there are brands!

But the build quality varies a lot, even among some of the so-called premium brands, because of the boom in sales in recent years and the pressure to push them out of the factory as fast as possible. Look for a well-looked-after, low-usage older van rather than a newer one with all the bells and whistles that's been thrashed/done a lot of work.

For a Commodore, I'd stay with a van under, say, 1800 kg ATM (Aggregate trailer Mass = all-up maximum weight), despite the 2150kg official rating of the vehicle. That probably means a large (~16') single axle or a small (maybe up to 18') tandem. A small tandem is likely to tow more stably.

If at all possible, before committing to a van, tow it (or get it towed) to a public weighbridge and get a true Tare weight. Compare this to the compliance plate figures. If the 'real' Tare is higher than the certified tare and not far below the ATM rating, this will limit the amount of gear that can legally be carried. (If a dealer won't agree to do this, you should question why and consider whether you want to deal with them...)

This can often happen because a lot of accessories like TVs, microwaves, roll-out awnings, etc, etc. are added after the van was tare weighed at the factory.

There are a lot of good "only used a few times" vans out there if you have time to look around. And with the current buoyant market, don't regard a first van as the one they have to stick with. It's easy to trade to a better/newer van in this market.
Ian
AnswerID: 263555

Follow Up By: shameem - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 17:45

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 17:45
If the ATM is 1700kg, the GTM of 1550 kg and Tare Mass of 1300kg - does that mean that you can load up a max of 400k or only 150 kg. What does the axle load capacity of 1600kg mean?
You seem to know what you are talking about Ian...thanks
shameem
0
FollowupID: 525222

Follow Up By: Ian from Thermoguard Instruments - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 19:32

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 19:32
Hi Shameem,

Thanks for the compliment.

The Tare of 1300kg should be the dead-empty weight of the van as it left the factory gates - without gas in the bottle, water in the tank(s) or any post-factory (read: dealer fitted) accessories.

GTM (Gross Trailer Mass) is the maximum weight allowed to be supported by the wheels and axles of the trailer/caravan. That is, it is the total maximum weight (ATM) less the weight on the tow ball.

ATM (Aggregate Trailer Mass) is the maximum overall weight of the van - the weight on the axles plus the weight on the tow ball.

So, if this particular van actually has an empty weight of 1300 kg (that is the dead-empty weight on the axle(s) plus the dead-empty weight on the ball), you can quite legally put 400kg of gas, water and belongings in it, PROVIDED that when it's fully loaded the total weight is no more than 1700kg AND the weight on the axle(s) is no more than 1550kg. Therefore, if the total weight WAS 1700kg, there would have to be NO MORE than 1550kg on the axle(s) and AT LEAST 150kg on the tow ball.

[A different but related issue is that with a ball weight of more than 140kg, you should be using a 250kg weight distribution hitch. None of the round bar systems, either 2 or 4-bar, are rated for a ball load of more than 140kg.]

There is one other common figure on caravan spec. plates - maximum axle group rating. This is usually quite a lot higher than the GTM/ATM figures but is not a particularly usable figure. It refers to the strength and load capacity of the axle, hubs and bearings. For typical axles using 14" wheels, each axle can support 1450kg (with Ford 'slimline' bearings), so a tandem axle van with two of these axles, the axle group rating will be 2900kg. For 'off road' vans with 15" or 16" wheels running on 4WD type hubs with parallel bearings (usually Toyota, Nissan or Land Rover types), the axle group rating could be quite a lot higher.

But it is very unlikely the chassis manufacturer (who usually sets the GTM) or the caravan builder (who usually measures the Tare and sets the ATM will rate their construction anywhere near the maximum axle group rating.

Your example seems a little unusual for a couple of reasons: Firstly the 'axle load capacity' of 1600kg suggests a stronger axle/hub/bearing design than the typical 14" wheel type - perhaps one with 4WD-type hubs? But it also suggests we're looking at a single axle van.

The difference between Tare and ATM (the "payload") is 400kg. The de facto industry 'standard' is typically a payload (ATM minus Tare) of 300kg for single axle vans and 400kg for tandem axle vans - but there's no strict reason why this must be so. So a 400kg payload for a single axle van seems to suggest we are looking at a single axle van with strong 4WD type axle/hubs and perhaps built by an up-market builder who constructed the van to handle a larger than average payload. Am I close?
0
FollowupID: 525239

Follow Up By: shameem - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:10

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:10
Ian...mate you are good!!
Just got a 2003 Olympic 2000 Series yesterday. With all the paperwork was all the details. It is a single axle. Wheel rim size/profile = 14 x 6; tyre size = 195 x 14, tyre pressure 320 kPa and all the previous information provided. Looks like a heavy duty setup (to the eye of someone with no experience). The weight distribution hitch "features the cam lock adjustable ball mount available in 250kg and 350kg hitch weights." It has two square bars and some pretty heavy duty chains (Hayman Reese). Who are you...what else can you tell me.
Regards
shameem
0
FollowupID: 525242

Follow Up By: Ian from Thermoguard Instruments - Monday, Sep 24, 2007 at 09:13

Monday, Sep 24, 2007 at 09:13
Hi Shameem,

Thanks again for the kind words - but don't get too carried away. We've picked up a bit in 5 /12 years living in and travelling extensively in caravans. [Please see About Us on our website for more details.]

But it's mostly stuff we've learned by reading the advice of REAL experts like Tom Olthoff. Tom was the technical writer for Caravan World magazine until they, in their infinite wisdom, dispensed with his services early this year - for very dubious reasons...

Malcolm Street's article on this site here has lots of good info, as do some of the other articles in the "Caravanning" section.

Your Hayman-Reese weight distribution hitch is excellent equipment, but must be set-up correctly to work properly. I'm frequently amazed at the number of caravanners with quality WD hitches which are doing next to nothing to level or stabilise the rig because of poor set-up. (Including many who say "But that's how the dealer set it up!")

Did you get the original H-R hitch instruction with the van and hitch? If not, I suggest you phone/email H-R to get a copy. Failing that, please feel free to email me for some tips on set-up. [Might even write it up into an article if there's enough interest.]

Ian
0
FollowupID: 525300

Follow Up By: shameem - Monday, Sep 24, 2007 at 10:03

Monday, Sep 24, 2007 at 10:03
Thanks Ian,
I googled Tom Olthoff and lots of links come up. I might start of new track and ask the question again in a few weeks to flash out the issue sthat come up. This might provide you with more incentive to do a writeup on hitch & tow iisues.

I love your website.
Regards
shameem
0
FollowupID: 525306

Reply By: bruce - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 10:06

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 10:06
18ft would be dual axle and for that price they should be able to get a used van in reasonbly good condition....look around the van yards...take your time...dont be pressured...good luck
AnswerID: 263557

Reply By: Jimbo Vic - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 10:16

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 10:16
Jayco Freedom is a ripper. 16.5 feet, 1250 kg dry weight.

Absolutely mint condition 2004 models can be had for about $22,000 including aircon.

Easy to tow behind a Commodore.

Mine will be in the trader section later today but I'm in Merlbourne so probably not of interest to you.

Cheers,

Jim.
AnswerID: 263561

Reply By: shameem - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:42

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:42
Hi Lyndon K,
Sorry about the side conversation with Ian. However, I am sure you are finding the information of great value. He obviously is someone with specialist knowledge that you and I could learn from. By the way, the van I just purchased is 17.5 feet single axle, full van, with a shower/toilet unit, double bed, twin gas bottles, no A/C. Included all the hitch, deep cycle battery system. Cost $23,500. I am a novice so I went for light and small even though I am towing wth a 100 series LC rated at 3500kg. Start small and upgrade later if needed.

They are out there at the price your parents are looking to pay. I did six months of research and search.
Regards
shameem
AnswerID: 263649

Follow Up By: Jimbo Vic - Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:44

Sunday, Sep 23, 2007 at 20:44
Fine advice
0
FollowupID: 525246

Reply By: Member - Arkay (SA) - Tuesday, Sep 25, 2007 at 13:44

Tuesday, Sep 25, 2007 at 13:44
We have a 2005 Jayco Heritage. All-be-it a tandem and probably a bit heavy for a Commodore. Jayco did not make a "dirt road" version of this van as they say their Millenium Chassis is good enough.
We only tow our van on bitumen roads, with the exception of a few very slow (max 40kph) km to a bush camp here & there. Actually we bush camp with it quite often.
If we want to go outback we find a bitumen road to get there or don't take the van at all. e.g. we keep clear of the Oodnadatta track. If we want to go serious 4WD we keep a tent & sleeping bags in the car and do day trips or a couple of nights under canvas, and "agist" the van at the caravan park for a few days. e.g we left the van at Alice Springs recently and toddled off down to Chambers Pillar without it. Most caravan parks will charge only a nominal or no fee for agistment, provided you stay with them before and after the outing.
P.S. the corrugations from Maryvale Station to Chambers Pillar were so deep you could have laid down and had a sleep between them. Actually I was a bit worried that thee might be someone lying down between them hidden in the dark shadows cast by the ridges.
AnswerID: 263859

Sponsored Links

Popular Products (9)