Thursday, Jan 28, 2010 at 15:56
I agree with Steve.
HF radio and satellite phones are different beasts each with their own advantages and disadvantages. Similar costs to setup but different costs to operate. The HF is somewhat like this
forum..... group activity and multiple assistance but not always easy to manage. A satellite phone is just like your mobile phone...... privacy and you speak directly with the person you want, provided you know who you want and they are available.
Telephone connection over HF is difficult to manage and often of inferior quality. Also difficult for others to contact you especially if you are not expecting the call.
HF is old technology. The transceivers have benefitted from progressive development but radio propagation cannot be improved. Satellite communication is however our most recent communication technology.
In the case of emergency, if you suffer from vehicle electrical failure, the
HF radio will be out of action, as it also will be if the antenna is damaged. Also if you are away from the vehicle, the HF is not available for emergency contact.
I have HF and have hired a satphone. If I had to do it all again I would purchase just a satphone.
And a comment about
UHF radio.
Mine was in the vehicle when I purchased it but I find it virtually useless. The only value I can see is if I were travelling in company with others. When I do turn it on, all I hear is others talking with each other about inconsequential matters and usually liberally punctuated with bad language. Someone may tell me how valuable UHF is for announcing your presence on tracks or dunes. But it's the idiot who doesn't hear you and who doesn't announce their presence who will hurtle around the bend. However, it does add another impressive antenna to the array on the front of my vehicle. LOL
FollowupID:
670822