Tuesday, Jan 22, 2013 at 11:45
Hi Peter
I see a few people who answered your question, have moved you on to other forms of emergency communication without answering your question.
You seem to be asking what is a fair price to pay for an EPIRB or PLB. I assume you have done some research so you have some idea of what you want to pay. From what you say, it sounds like you are looking for a PLB, as your trip around Australia appears to be on land. If cost is your primary concern, then perhaps you might want to also consider hiring one.
For assessing emergency solutions, there is no perfect answer to your question. Having been involved in 4WDing for many years, and travelled a lot of outback country, the
feedback I can give you is that it is always nice to have an emergency tool that is 2 way. Having personally rung for assistance when are vehicle
broke down 5 years ago, it was very calming for us to be able to talk to someone via
HF radio to have ourselves recovered. In another situation, I also used HF to gain information of the nearest medical help, after a winching accident. That information was very helpful to me.
Thesedays, we travel with a SPOT unit,
HF radio & Sat phone. SPOT is great for letting our friends follow our trip. It has an emergency button which will call in emergency
services if we activate it. This function is similar to an EPRIB. The biggest downside with SPOT & EPRIBs are that they are one way. i.e. you activate it, but you have no idea what is being done to rescue you until help arrives - this could be 4 hours or it could be 48 hours - you don't know - you just have to wait, while your stress levels increase with time.
The other issue to think about is, is my situation really an emergency? OR am I activating my emergency device because I have no other way of communicating with someone else. As the stats show, there has been a lot of activations for incidence that were not considered "an emergency". A good example was when are 4WD
broke down in far west SA. We used our HF to organise a recovery vehicle from Nullarbor. Had we seen anyone for a couple of days, and had run out of
food & water, and with the temperature in the high 30's each day, we might then consider it an emergency. But if we only had SPOT, would have we hit the SOS button because we had no other form of communication.
For peace of mind, I personally think that a communication device that allows you to talk to someone else, is of far greater benefit. HF radios cost a lot of money but are cheap to run. Sat Phones are reasonably priced, but you will have ongoing costs to continue with them. However, the advantage of a 2 way device is that the person you speak to may be able to give you helpful advice, and also lower your level of stress. Also, if medical assistance is needed quickly, communicating via HF or Sat phone may get the medical people (such as RFDS) to you much quicker than SPOT or an EPIRB, as the medical assistance wont be organised until the emergency response people arrived at your location & assess the situation.
Someone mentioned inReach. This is similar to SPOT but has the added advantage of 2 way text messaging. One issue with text messaging is that you are reliant on the person your are texting, is available to text you back. You dont know why that havent texted back if you havent heard from them. The advantage of a voice call is that you know very quickly if the person you call is able to talk to you. They may also offer some help which you hadn't thought of.
You also mention UHF. This has a limited use in an emergency situation. You will know that you are dependent on line of site to another user.Repeaters can help here, but there will be many times in the outback when this is not an option. Carrying 2 hand held UHF radios are good for personal communication where you recovery is away from your vehicle.
I finish off by saying there is no one perfect solution. Having more than one form of effective outbback communication is the key to outback travel. The biggest issue I would face (when in an emergency situation) is assessing whether my situation is really an emergency, or am I just using the emergency
tools I have because that is all I have.
Laurie
AnswerID:
503136
Follow Up By: Member - David M (SA) - Tuesday, Jan 22, 2013 at 12:12
Tuesday, Jan 22, 2013 at 12:12
Hi Laurie. I like to think that a good rule of thumb when assessing the emergency is:
1 broken leg.Drag yourself out.
2 broken legs.Press the button.
Cheers,Dave
FollowupID:
779758
Follow Up By: Member - Scott M (NSW) - Wednesday, Jan 23, 2013 at 11:39
Wednesday, Jan 23, 2013 at 11:39
David, disagree ....
1 broken leg. I'd press the button if I was in a remote location...
FollowupID:
779851
Follow Up By: Zebra400 - Thursday, Jan 24, 2013 at 05:30
Thursday, Jan 24, 2013 at 05:30
Guys, this is exactly one of my points. Both of you have a different opinion as to what is an emergency. Now if you had an HF or
Sat phone for 2 way comms, then you might have found that by talking to someone, there may be a different solution than calling in the big guns to rescue you.
Laurie
FollowupID:
779917
Follow Up By: Member - Scott M (NSW) - Thursday, Jan 24, 2013 at 21:16
Thursday, Jan 24, 2013 at 21:16
Zebra, I agree people have different opinions - I was only responding to the example posed by David.
Frankly, half way along the AB or CSR I aint driving out with a broken leg. Air lift with a RFDS is the best option. Whether we Sat call, HF, or
epirb, ... whatever is more effective. However the 'big guns' would tell you this is the correct option...
FollowupID:
779958