some promising figures justiying a CT
Submitted: Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 16:53
ThreadID:
44375
Views:
3670
Replies:
9
FollowUps:
14
This Thread has been Archived
Member - Tonester (VIC)
Hi all. It was a bunch of people on this
forum who really persuaded us to get a CT, esp rather than a larger tent setup to gear for our growing family,
young kids, etc. The calls for a CT were overwhelming.
So now, its a year and a bit later, and 55 nights in the thing (just did the math). CT cost approx $11000, with some $3000 later on other accessories/luxuries, making around $14000.
With 55 nights at a nominal $200 a night (family of 5 is not cheap) come to the original $11000.
The CT just got paid for.
Tell ya, I'm happy!
Reply By: Robin - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 20:03
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 20:03
Come on Tone , I think I could invent a set of figures to support a no camper case - I won't be getting a camper or automatic until physical restraints force them apon me , but my wife would love to see your figures - but I won't let her see them and I tell her that -->
It costs on average $56 a night for an onsite van (Port Germain recently)
Camper costs $26 a nite in same place - so nett cost is only $30 per night
we save 15% on fuel by not towing - ($25 per 600km day )
Campers depreciate
Campers require maintenance including tyres etc
With camper on van you take much more complex equipment with higher capital costs
Towing anything reduces your primary saftey factor
Towing anything reduces the number of tracks you can drive
Our latest tent cost $29
By working out all the above factors - we calculate that the further we drive the more we save with the $11000 in the bank espically as most of time we
free camp.
By now I've won the arguement but I lock it in and terrifying her by saying she'd have to back in it sometimes
Only problem is snakes get into tents more easily - but I'm working on that !
Robin Miller
AnswerID:
233857
Follow Up By: Member - Tonester (VIC) - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 20:16
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 20:16
whats the smiley face thing for flipping the bird in email?? lol
My missus drove ours fully over
easter, a little worried at first but worked out that its not hard. My yelling to stop cutting corners got through eventually too.
FollowupID:
494761
Reply By: Crackles - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 21:24
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 21:24
I think you have over simplified the sums a little Tone. Trailer registration, insurance & additional fuel to tow the camper have got to be added in too. Pre trip servicing & of course running repairs & new tyres will eventually come around. Then you've compared the cost of putting a family up in a serviced appartment ($200) Vs camping under canvas. When we stop in cabins the family & I rarely pay more than $130 anyway for a decent roof over over our head & it has air con & real beds for everyone. Then of course you forgot that if you had bought a tent then you would still have a lazy $10,000 to invest which this year would have made 15% in interest, that's $1500 compounding annually which means yet another 7 nights each year you need to
camp to justify this purchase. Then if you do decide to stay in a caravan park they'll charge you almost double for a site compared to a tent & really you're still only camping.
A mate did the sums a few years ago & he found when the additional cost of the 4 wheel drive, assesories & camping equipment was taken into account it was actually cheaper to fly to his destination, stay in 4 star hotels & pay tour opperators to show his family of 4 around for the 3 weeks of holidays he took each year compared to camping.
Of course camping offers a completely different experience with far greater flexability so really shouldn't be compared but does go to show it is not quite as cheap as one would think particually when buying expensive items like camper trailers.
But don't worry too much though as you forgot that the trailer is still worth at least $8,000 & if you were to sell it then it would actually have only cost you $55 per night so far in real terms:-) (+ of course all those other expenses you forgot to add ;-)
Cheers Craig.................
PS: Not that I'm against camper trailers as I'm looking at building one myself.
AnswerID:
233887
Follow Up By: Russ n Sue - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 21:59
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 21:59
Well I reckon that all those "tenters" are driving around Oz grossly overweight (vehicle wise). At least with a camper you can carry another tonne of crap with you and if you do it right, still be legal. And if you you really prefer erecting a tent and stuffing around with matresses,
camp beds etc instead of throwing open the camper and flopping onto a decent bed, then you have rocks in your head.
And who cares about snakes? It's those really big water loving lizards that worry me when I see people in a tent.
FollowupID:
494790
Follow Up By: Crackles - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 22:29
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 22:29
Of course I would rather the decent bed but Russ you missed the point of the thread, Tone was justifying the campers cost not how great the features are.
As far as the features & convienience goes
well that's another issue. I can set up my complete
camp, tent, air mats, etc in 15 minutes on my own. (actually quicker without the kids helping) To set up a
Tambo camper like Tone's I watched one being errected at Xmas & it took 1 hour by the time they sat down. I was so physically exhausted watching them I had to have another drink:-)) And as for the big lizards do you actually think the canvas is any tougher between the kids sleeping on the floor in the
Tambo camper compared to the canvas in a Freedom tent ;-)
Cheers Craig................
FollowupID:
494807
Follow Up By: Member - Tonester (VIC) - Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 22:54
Monday, Apr 16, 2007 at 22:54
man, too hard... I like my CT.
I bet I can set up my CT quicker than it would for a cabin tent, which is the equiv.
FollowupID:
494815
Follow Up By: D-Jack - Tuesday, Apr 17, 2007 at 11:29
Tuesday, Apr 17, 2007 at 11:29
Crackles, where on earth can I get 15% interest from, unless you just looked at your 1986 term deposit interest rates ;)
FollowupID:
494875
Reply By: Member - Duncs - Tuesday, Apr 17, 2007 at 14:22
Tuesday, Apr 17, 2007 at 14:22
Did a trip out to
Lake Eyre a few years ago.
Sydney to
Ballina (scenic route)
Ballina to
Bourke then via Camerons Corner to
Lyndhurst, Maree, Mulloorina, William Crk.
Home via
Flinders Ranges, motel in
Broken Hill 'cause we felt like it. I kept logs on that trip and did the maths when we got
home. WIth 5 on board it worked out at $28 per person per day, including souvenirs.
The crunch is that without the camper we would not have gone. Neither would we have gone to WA for 6 weeks, western Victoria, Cape
Yorke,
Simpson Desert,
Flinders Ranges (more than once)
Innamincka, or on any of the other outback trips. The camper is sooooo comfortable and quick, the missus won't
camp any other way. I had a great tent, only took 45 min to put up. Then I got to start on all the other stuff. And because there are 5 of us I was towing a trailer anyway, might as
well have the camper.
We have had ours for 11 years now. On tonesters maths I should be a millionaire, I should have paid more attnetion to Mr Cameron when I was at school.
Duncs
Duncs
AnswerID:
233974