Thursday, Dec 23, 2010 at 11:07
I bought the MY50T a year ago. Unless you're driving in
Sydney, it's terrible!
The CPU is too slow for a start. Playing ANY sound, even the turn announcements, completely locks up the entire unit until the sounds stops playing. That's how underpowered it is.
I have had the mainboard repalced once because the battery failed to hold charge, and only 3 months laterm it looks like it's on the way out again. Went from 54% to 18% in 2 minutes in walking mode.
It's terrible for regional streets, but have to admit, for NSW
State Forest tracks it hasn't let me down completely yet. But it does get VERY VERY confused, and has taken me around 3 laps to get out of Green Hills SF a while back.
Brisbane is terrible. The turn announcements are approx 10m AFTER you have passed the turn. It's like the whole GPS is 200m behind where you actually are.
Melbourne &
Adelaide are not great either.
I installed iGo8 on a mate's ALDI goCruise unit, and it's better at everything. Found streets in Yass the Navman couldn't, has smart street input, better announcements, and user interface. But the display is a bit cluttered.
I set my Navman side by side with a TomTom unit in
Sydney and the TomTom announced turns clearer & earlier than the Navman did. Little things like "Turn right, then get in the left lane to turn left in 100m" were a god send from the TomTom where my Navman simplay said "Turn right, ........Turn left".
And finally, I find the removal of an "ignition" sense, that automatically turns off the GPS when the external power is removed, (like all the S series did!!!) a real backward step.
Likewise is the ability to DISPLAY the GPS Co-Ordinates of where you currently are. I mean, what GPS device couldn't do that natively? The MY50 you have to DOWNLOAD a Saved Point to NavDesk software, THEN transport that to Google maps and read the Co-Ords from there. Sorry, but I don't carry a laptop and google maps in my pocket, and shouldn't have to. It's such a ridiculous thing to remove from the software of a GPS unit!
It does sound like the MY75T has fixed a lot of the problems the MY5x series had. But considering the MY50T was $400 when I bought
mine, and they can now be found for close to half that ($235 @ Dick Smith) only 1 year later, AND they now throw in free maps for 3 years to shift them as
well, I'm thinking I bought a lemon. I'll wait another 6 months and see if the price on the MY75T crashes like my MY50 did. That might be a good indicator if they turn out to be a lemon as
well? I'll certainly be looking at a TomTom or Garmin next time. But it does sound like people are happy with the new Navmans??
AnswerID:
439635
Follow Up By: Member - John & Lil - Thursday, Dec 23, 2010 at 11:26
Thursday, Dec 23, 2010 at 11:26
I must have a different model MY75T. I bought my new Navman in
Brisbane on a recent trip after my old Sat Nav went to God. In my opinion I thought it worked great in
Brisbane and all the way back to here in
Melbourne. We came back via Cunamulla,
Bourke,
Griffith. I was accurate all the way. I do around 800klms a week in
Melbourne here and use the MY75T extensively and find it very good. I was impressed with how accurate the speed changes happen on the MY75T as one passes the change of speed signs on the side of the road. I may be easy to please but I love the MY75T.
FollowupID:
711533
Follow Up By: Wiz.au - Thursday, Dec 23, 2010 at 12:07
Thursday, Dec 23, 2010 at 12:07
Hi John / Lil,
My comments are in relation to the previous model, the MY50T/MY55T.
But you have reminded me of ANOTHER issue with it. It warns me about speed changes alright....yeah,...GOING THE WRONG WAY!
If I am leaving a 60Kph zone and entering a 100Kph zone, when I get to the 100Kph
sign, it warns me when I hit it that there is a speed change _TO_ _60kph_ and then counts _UP_ in meters as I drive away from the
sign.
Exactly the OPPOSITE of what it should do.
And if I am driving the OTHER way, from the 100Kph into the 60Kph zone, it doesn't warn me _AT_ALL_.
This feature is simply plain broken on my model, even with the latest firmware update that now includes for free the adaptable speed warning system the MY55T came with. Glad I didn't spend the extra $80 on that feature, cause now all MY50T users get it for free in the latest update anyway. I'd be royally bleep ed if I bought an MY55T to get this feature and paid the extra.
FollowupID:
711535